The only unit Ops could keep running at 35°C
Cofimco fan blade upgrade. Shell expected the gains would let them drop plans to replace the coolers.
“In the 35 C weather yesterday, looks like the upgraded unit was the only one Ops could keep running… I am guessing that the improvements are going to be enough that we can rule out future plans to replace our units.”
David Bailey, P.Eng., Facilities Engineer, Brownfield Projects, Shell CanadaBC · 2021 · Nick Agius, consulting
Running above 30°C for the first time
Five fans across two trains converted from Moore to Cofimco, with inlet bells, tip seals and new longer fan rings.
“Our run time in hot weather is much better.”
Rod Whelen, Obsidian Energy2018 · Our team at Motion Industries Canada
Outlet gas 20 to 24°C cooler
Belt drive upgrade, installed by our field crew.
“We have seen an outlet gas temp reduction of somewhere between 20-24 C lower than it was previous to this upgrade work being conducted.”
Quinton North, TC Energy (TCPL)Acme compressor station, AB · 2018 · Our team at Motion Industries Canada
No production cuts at 34°C
16 fans converted from low efficiency Moore to high efficiency Cofimco-Hudson, tip speed raised from 8,000 to 10,000 fpm, timing belts, inlet bells and DG-II Anti Rotation Devices®. About 50% more airflow projected from the existing horsepower, backed by HTRI runs. Before the upgrade the plant cut production at 30 to 31°C.
“We did not have to cut production as the fans did their job this time.”
Randy Peterson, Plant Maintenance Planner, Husky Energy (now Cenovus)Tucker Lake SAGD, AB · 2018 · Our team at Motion Industries Canada
Duty up from 3 to 4 to about 7 MMBtu/h
New fans plus internal and external bundle cleaning, on a cooler designed for 5.2 MMBtu/h.
“Now with the new fans and the cleanings both internally and externally, we were getting around 7 in the warmer fall weather!! Big improvement.”
Carolyn Butler, ShellSarnia, cooler CC-704, ON · 2017 · Our team at Motion Industries Canada
Approach temperature down 5°C
Air cooler fan upgrade. Discharge temperature rose only 5°C through a 10°C rise in ambient.
“Our approach temp is down 5deg from prior to the upgrade, and our final discharge temp is up only 5deg in the last month, despite the 10deg increase in ambient.”
Paul Emberton, Operations Specialist, CDU Production Engineering, Repsol Oil & Gas Canada (formerly Talisman)Wild River, K-101, AB · 2017 · Our team at Motion Industries Canada
Enough extra cooling to lock out more fans for the rebuild
After only 4 of 22 fans were upgraded, operations reported enough added cooling capacity to lock out more than one fan at a time for the rest of the rebuild.
Devon EnergyJackfish 2, AB · 2017 · Our team at Motion Industries Canada
$2 to 4 million a year in economic profit
Site visits and performance data, fan modelling and airflow improvements. A fouling problem was diagnosed and a cleaning specialist brought in.
“We implemented solutions to improve our fan performance and increase production resulting in an economic profit of $2-4 million/year.”
Darcy Broen, Polyethylene Train 2 Technical Advisor, Dow Chemical CanadaFort Saskatchewan Polyethylene, AB · c. 2016 · Our team at Motion Industries Canada
$1.56 million in value in under four months
Fan capacity upgrade on the SM column coolers, backed by Nick's airflow testing. Value measured May to mid August 2016.
“Believe the numbers below are, if anything, understating the value… Excellent work, thank Nick Agius for me please.”
Stephen Huber, NOVA ChemicalsJoffre, AB · 2016 · Our team at Motion Industries Canada
+19% cooling duty
Bundle cleaning, higher fan speed, a blade tip change and a tip seal.
“Yes it is +19% cooling duty. A real home run for this cooler.”
Kristen McGlone, E.I.T., Maintenance, Dow Chemical CanadaFort Saskatchewan, cooler E206, AB · 2016 · Our team at Motion Industries Canada
Full capacity through the summer heat
Two new fans for process and engine cooling, with a 3 to 4 degree improvement.
“We saw a significant change (3-4 degree change) with the new fans. These new fans allowed our operations team to run our units a full capacity in the heat of the summer.”
Lance McKinnon, Sr Facilities Engineer, TAQA North2016 · Our team at Motion Industries Canada
Noticeable improvement on four coolers
New Cofimco and Hudson fans, inlet bells, tip seals, poly chain belt drives, upsized shafts and bearings, anti-rotation devices and structural repairs.
“Overall the work was much needed and I am certain we are realizing benefits.”
Philip Nearing, P.Eng., Sr Process Engineer, Husky Energy (now Cenovus)Prince George Refinery, BC · 2016 · Our team at Motion Industries Canada
Flare reduction worth about $270,000 a year
Manual pitch adjustment devices repaired, air side bundle cleaning, pitch adjustment and fan replacement, and the tower adjusted to its new operating pressure. Later, poly chain belts and a fixed hub upgrade.
“All the changes contributed to a flare reduction estimated at $270K/year.”
Andrew Cameron, Continuous Improvement Specialist, Imperial OilStrathcona Refinery, AB · Our team at Motion Industries Canada
$250,000 more throughput every summer
Hudson B blades upgraded to the Hudson HC series: 6°C better on 12 fans and 4°C on two more.
“This translates into a $250,000 more throughput for Scotford on our CCR each and every summer from this point forward.”
Matt Pickard, ShellScotford Refinery, AB · 2009 · Our team at Motion Industries Canada
Up to 50% more airflow, and much lower vibration
An installer partner's report of a retrofit to Nick Agius's MOC package. The shaft, sheaves, belts and motor were reused; only the fan changed and a tip seal was added. Airflow was up to 50% higher than the original Moore fan.
Brandon Wever, Millwright and Owner, Wever, installer partnera SAGD site · Installer partner report